Leadership 5 min readNovember 12, 2026

Should You Replace an Underperforming Executive? How to Decide

Replace an executive when the gap is capability or conduct, not unclear goals or missing resources. A time-boxed test for founders and CEOs.

NA

NeuroAgent Editorial

Editorial Team

The short answer

Replace an underperforming executive when the gap lies in capability or conduct for the stage your company is in now, not when it is caused by unclear goals, missing resources or a role you designed badly. Separate those causes first, set a time-boxed plan with written criteria, and decide on the evidence when the deadline arrives. Hesitation is common even at the top: a 2022 Stanford GSB article on research by David Larcker, Brian Tayan and Edward Watts reports that 4 out of 10 CEOs keep their jobs despite five years of worst-in-class performance on return on assets (Stanford GSB, 2022).

Should You Replace an Underperforming Executive? How to Decide — a NeuroAgent Leadership research illustration

Most executive replacement decisions go wrong on timing, not on the verdict.

Founders often sense the problem months before they act, then spend those months hoping it fixes itself. Some patience is justified: Gartner research on executive transitions found that 39% of transitioning executives underperformed, needing more time than successful peers to reach their initial job objectives (Gartner, 2025). That figure comes from a research abstract focused on CIOs, so treat it as a signal that a slow start is common, not as proof that it is harmless. Waiting also has a price. Spencer Stuart analyzed more than 1,850 Russell 3000 CEO transitions between 2007 and 2017 and found that roughly one-third of companies achieved turnarounds and restored growth; its conclusion was that the longer boards take to act when performance declines, the harder it is to improve (Spencer Stuart, 2021). That data covers listed companies and CEOs, but the dynamic applies to a 100-person firm with a struggling VP just as well.

Diagnose the cause before you judge the person.

Run through four questions, in this order. Clarity: were the goals, decision rights and success measures written down and agreed, or did they shift every quarter? Capacity: did the executive get the budget, team and time the plan assumed? Capability: does the person have the skills the role needs at this stage, which may differ from the stage you hired for? Conduct: are there issues of trust, integrity or how they treat people? If the answer points to clarity or capacity, the first fix is yours, and replacing the executive would simply hand the same problem to a successor. If it points to capability or conduct, replacement belongs on the table, and serious conduct issues may not warrant a long improvement period at all.

Use a five-question decision test.

First, knowing what you know today, would you hire this person for this role again? Second, what exactly would have to be true in 90 days for you to keep them, and can you measure it? Third, what does each month of waiting cost in team attrition, stalled decisions and customer trust? Fourth, how reversible is each option? Keeping someone one more quarter is easy to undo; a replacement is not, so it deserves the more careful process, as we explain in our guide to reversible vs. irreversible decisions. Fifth, what is your cover plan: an internal successor, an interim or fractional leader, or a temporary split of the role? If you cannot answer the fifth question, you are not ready to decide, whichever way you lean.

More on Leadership — every week.

Join 2,400+ leaders getting the decision intelligence briefing.

Time-box the improvement plan and write the criteria down.

Agree three to five observable outcomes for a fixed period, typically 60 to 90 days, with short check-ins along the way. Record the plan, the reasoning and the agreed criteria in your decision log, so that the final call rests on what was agreed rather than on the latest impression. Before the deadline, run a quick pre-mortem on both paths: imagine it is a year later and keeping the person failed, then imagine replacing them failed, and list the reasons each time. Then decide on the date you set, and do not let the plan quietly extend. In Germany and much of Europe, employment law, contract terms and works council rules shape how and when you can act, so involve an employment lawyer early; this article is not legal advice.

Hypothetical example.

A 120-person software company hired a VP Sales nine months ago, and pipeline is running well below plan. The diagnosis shows mixed causes: the CEO changed the territory model twice (clarity) and froze sales hiring for a quarter (capacity), but two senior account executives also left, citing management style (conduct and capability). The CEO first fixes the territory model and releases two hires, then sets a 90-day plan with three measures: pipeline coverage back to target, no further regretted attrition, and a forecast that lands within an agreed range. In parallel, the CEO quietly identifies a fractional sales leader as cover. At day 90 the pipeline has recovered, but another account executive has resigned for the same reason. The CEO decides to replace the VP, and because the cover plan already exists, the transition takes weeks rather than months. This scenario is illustrative and does not describe a real company.

Get an outside challenge before an irreversible people call.

Decisions about senior people are where founders are most likely to decide alone, and where loyalty, sunk cost and conflict avoidance distort judgment the most. A board member, an experienced peer or an advisor who will argue the opposite case is worth more here than another week of reflection. If you want a structured challenge, you can describe the situation in the NeuroAgent council at /try, where AI advisors debate the case for and against and an AI-assisted boundary check tests the result against the constraints you set. Whichever route you choose, the goal is the same: a decision made on written criteria and on time, not one made by default.

Research context

Only 20% of respondents to McKinsey's global survey said their organizations excelled at decision making.

McKinsey & Company: Decision making in the age of urgency (2019)

This independently published statistic provides context for the topic; it does not substantiate every claim in this essay.

executive hiringleadership decisionsperformance management

One decision framework, every week.

The week's best articles on making and executing high-stakes decisions, backed by sourced research.

Send me the weekly Decision Intelligence newsletter (unsubscribe anytime). Privacy Policy

More from the blog

See it in action

Run your next important decision through a NeuroAgent council in under 5 minutes.

Launch a Council